Supreme Court Clarifies Ruling on Proof of Resistance in Rape Cases

- Advertisement -

Victims of rape are no longer required to prove resistance if the crime was committed through force, threats, or intimidation.

This clarification comes from a recent Supreme Court (SC) ruling.

- Advertisement -

In a June 2024 decision penned by Associate Justice Maria Filomena Singh, the SC upheld the conviction of a father who was found guilty of repeatedly raping his daughter from the ages of nine to sixteen.

The SC reaffirmed Article 266-A of the Revised Penal Code, which defines rape as occurring when sexual intercourse is forced, threatened, or coerced; when the victim is unconscious; through deception or abuse of authority; or when the victim is under 12 years old or suffers from a mental disability.

The SC clarified that in cases where rape happens under these conditions, the mere occurrence of the sexual act is sufficient to establish the crime.

Additionally, the SC overturned its previous stance, which implied that a woman must prove resistance to claim she was raped.

- Advertisement -

The High Court emphasized that such views perpetuate misguided stereotypes, gender bias, and insensitivity.

The ruling also dispelled the notion that failure to resist implies consent, stating that this belief is unacceptable in modern society.

Furthermore, the SC highlighted that, in many cases, the perpetrator is someone the victim knows or is close to, such as a family member.

In cases where a child is abused by a parent, the victim is unlikely to resist due to the abuser’s physical and moral authority.

- Advertisement -

Latest

ICC Prosecutors ask appeals chamber to deny Duterte defense request for extra filings

THE International Criminal Court (ICC) prosecution has urged the...

Sara Duterte, OVP, DepEd officials face plunder complaints over confidential funds

CIVILS society groups filed plunder, bribery, and malversation complaints...

DILG downplays alleged threats to contractor Sarah Discaya amid flood control probe

THE Department of the Interior and Local Government (DILG)...

Sandiganbayan rejects bid to merge cases vs. Zaldy Co, DPWH officials over Mindoro flood project

THE Sandiganbayan’s Fifth Division has denied the prosecution’s request...

Sara Discaya to Remain in NBI Detention Pending Court Arrest Warrant

Sara Discaya will continue to stay at the National...

Newsletter

Thailand launches airstrikes on Cambodia as Trump-backed peace deal nears breakdown

THAILAND carried out airstrikes against Cambodia on Monday after fresh fighting flared along the two countries’ disputed border, raising doubts over the survival of...

Roque asks Interpol oversight body to dismiss PH Red Notice request

FORMER presidential spokesperson Harry Roque has urged the Commission for the Control of Interpol’s Files (CCF) to reject the Philippine government’s request for a...

VP Sara says impeachment threat being used as ‘Bargaining Chip’ ahead of 2026 budget

VICE President Sara Duterte on Monday claimed that renewed talk of an impeachment complaint against her is being wielded by some lawmakers as leverage...